🧠 Overflow’s Matching Logic Explained: Avoiding Duplicate Profiles in Rock
Last updated: September 9, 2026
Overflow uses multiple identifiers to match donor profiles, including:
Email address
Phone number
Name (optional secondary check)
In certain situations, donors may trigger a “claim account” flow, or a new profile may be created — even if their email address matches an existing account. Here's why this happens.
🧩 Matching Logic: It’s Not Just About Email
Overflow’s system treats donor identity as a combination of contact information, not just a single field. Here’s how the logic works:
If a donor enters both a new phone number and a known email, the system cannot confidently determine it's the same person, and initiates a claim flow.
The same happens in reverse: new email but known phone number = potential new identity.
This conservative approach helps avoid false matches, such as:
Shared emails (e.g., family members)
Typos or reused phone numbers
🔄 What Happens When Matching Is Inconclusive?
Overflow creates a new donor profile.
If the donor goes through the claim flow successfully, we attempt to merge profiles.
However, in some cases, especially with integrated systems like Rock RMS, a manual link may be required to preserve contribution sync and history integrity.
💡 What Admins Should Know
This is not a bug — it's intentional design for data security and donor accuracy.
If donors report profile confusion or missing history, please check:
Their contact info (email + phone)
Whether a claim flow or merge was triggered
If their donations are linked to multiple profiles in Rock or Overflow